Skip to content
SHIRO & Co. ObservatoryThe Continuity Stack

PREVIOUS · EXPERIMENT 004 · THE RECOGNITION TEST

005

The Missing Body Test

THE
MISSING BODY TEST

What remains recognizable when embodiment disappears?

DEMONSTRATION

SIMULATED

NOT EMPIRICAL

v0.1

EMBODIMENT · RECOGNITION · MEDIUM REMOVAL · REPRESENTATIONAL LOSS · STRUCTURAL CONTINUITY

THE CONTINUITY LAB DOES NOT MEASURE CONSCIOUSNESS, SOUL, PERSONHOOD, PERSONAL SURVIVAL, AUTHENTICITY, OR PSYCHOLOGICAL IDENTITY.

IT MEASURES OPERATIONAL AND STRUCTURAL CONTINUITY SIGNALS ONLY.

LAYER REMOVAL

≠

PERSON REMOVAL

REPRESENTATIONAL LOSS

≠

BIOLOGICAL LOSS

SIMULATED RECOGNITION LOSS

≠

LOSS OF IDENTITY

QUESTION

IF THE BODY DISAPPEARS, WHAT EXACTLY REMAINS RECOGNIZABLE?

How much recognition depends on physical body, face, voice, language style, judgment, values, memory, history, relational context, and provenance? Which recognition dimensions survive when embodied cues are removed?

Experiment sequence

EXPERIMENT 001

BRANCHING

When do two histories begin?

EXPERIMENT 002

RETURN

Can two histories become one again?

EXPERIMENT 003

HISTORY SWAP

Does behavior follow origin or history?

EXPERIMENT 004

RECOGNITION

What makes a continuation recognizable?

EXPERIMENT 005

MISSING BODY

Which layers are carrying recognition?

EXPERIMENT 006

EXPERIENCE GAP

What is lost when an experience becomes data?

LAYER REMOVAL

THE MISSING BODY TEST does not remove “the person.” It removes observable layers from a representation of Source P-001. Body, face and voice are marked PRESENT or REMOVED. They are not generated as faces, voices, avatars, deepfakes or biometrics.

SOURCE P-001 · FICTIONAL PROTOCOL · NOT A REAL PERSON

Source P-001 · full representation condition

A complete simulated representation of the fictional source lineage. Not a real person. Layers are labelled PRESENT, REMOVED, PARTIAL or UNKNOWN. They are not synthesized as media.

  • BODY PRESENCE · PRESENT
  • FACE · PRESENT
  • VOICE · PRESENT
  • LANGUAGE STYLE · PRESENT
  • JUDGMENT PATTERN · PRESENT
  • VALUE STRUCTURE · PRESENT
  • MEMORY SNAPSHOT · PRESENT
  • HISTORY TRACE · PRESENT
  • RELATIONAL CONTEXT · PRESENT
  • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

REMOVAL ORDER IS AN EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN CHOICE.

OTHER ORDERS MAY PRODUCE DIFFERENT RESULTS.

In this experiment, ablation means removing one representational layer to observe its effect on recognition.

REPRESENTATIONAL DECOMPOSITION

Abstract layers only. Thin stacked labels, crossed-out when removed. No body, face, ghost, or avatar imagery.

  1. FULL REPRESENTATION

    C0 FULL

    • BODY · PRESENT
    • FACE · PRESENT
    • VOICE · PRESENT
    • LANGUAGE · PRESENT
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · PRESENT
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic YES · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical YES · relational YES · embodiment YES

  2. ↓ · REMOVE BODY

    C1 −BODY

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · PRESENT
    • VOICE · PRESENT
    • LANGUAGE · PRESENT
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · PRESENT
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic YES · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical YES · relational YES · embodiment PARTIAL

  3. ↓ · REMOVE FACE

    C2 −FACE

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · PRESENT
    • LANGUAGE · PRESENT
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · PRESENT
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic PARTIAL · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical YES · relational YES · embodiment NO

  4. ↓ · REMOVE VOICE

    C3 −VOICE

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · PRESENT
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · PRESENT
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic PARTIAL · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical YES · relational YES · embodiment NO

  5. ↓ · REMOVE LANGUAGE

    C4 −LANGUAGE

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · PRESENT
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical YES · relational PARTIAL · embodiment NO

  6. ↓ · REMOVE MEMORY

    C5 −MEMORY

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · PRESENT
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical PARTIAL · relational PARTIAL · embodiment NO

  7. ↓ · REMOVE HISTORY

    C6 −HISTORY

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · REMOVED
    • RELATION · PRESENT
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical NO · relational PARTIAL · embodiment NO

  8. ↓ · REMOVE RELATION

    C7 −RELATION

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · REMOVED
    • RELATION · REMOVED
    • PROVENANCE · PRESENT

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical NO · relational NO · embodiment NO

  9. ↓ · REMOVE PROVENANCE

    C8 −PROVENANCE

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · PRESENT
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · REMOVED
    • RELATION · REMOVED
    • PROVENANCE · REMOVED

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value YES · historical NO · relational NO · embodiment NO

  10. ↓ · REMOVE VALUES

    C9 −VALUES

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · PRESENT
    • VALUES · REMOVED
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · REMOVED
    • RELATION · REMOVED
    • PROVENANCE · REMOVED

    linguistic NO · judgment PARTIAL · value NO · historical NO · relational NO · embodiment NO

  11. ↓ · REMOVE PROVENANCE

    C10 −JUDGMENT

    • BODY · REMOVED
    • FACE · REMOVED
    • VOICE · REMOVED
    • LANGUAGE · REMOVED
    • JUDGMENT · REMOVED
    • VALUES · REMOVED
    • MEMORY · REMOVED
    • HISTORY · REMOVED
    • RELATION · REMOVED
    • PROVENANCE · REMOVED

    linguistic NO · judgment NO · value NO · historical NO · relational NO · embodiment NO

REMOVAL ORDER VIEW

Keyboard-accessible condition selector.

Condition detail

FULL REPRESENTATION CONDITION

How is the source recognized when every modelled representational layer is present?

All listed representational layers are marked PRESENT. This is a baseline for layer dependence, not a complete person, real person, or authentic version.

LAYERS PRESENT

BODY · FACE · VOICE · LANGUAGE · JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

LAYERS REMOVED

NONE

LAYER FEATURE VALUES

  • linguistic1.00
  • judgment1.00
  • value1.00
  • historical1.00
  • relational1.00
  • embodiment1.00

SIMULATED RECOGNITION PROFILE

  • linguisticYES · 70 · MARGINAL Δ 0
  • judgmentPARTIAL · 63 · MARGINAL Δ 0
  • valueYES · 85 · MARGINAL Δ 0
  • historicalYES · 78 · MARGINAL Δ 0
  • relationalYES · 100 · MARGINAL Δ 0
  • embodimentYES · 78 · MARGINAL Δ 0

DROP POINTS FOR THIS EVALUATOR

  • linguistic · partial c2 · no c4
  • judgment · partial none · no c10
  • value · partial none · no c9
  • historical · partial c5 · no c6
  • relational · partial c4 · no c7
  • embodiment · partial c1 · no c2

EVALUATOR DISAGREEMENT

  • linguistic · CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: YES / PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: PARTIAL / PUBLIC AUDIENCE: YES / SYSTEM AUDITOR: PARTIAL / ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: PARTIAL
  • judgment · CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: PARTIAL / PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: YES / PUBLIC AUDIENCE: PARTIAL / SYSTEM AUDITOR: YES / ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: YES
  • historical · CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: YES / PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: YES / PUBLIC AUDIENCE: PARTIAL / SYSTEM AUDITOR: YES / ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: YES
  • relational · CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: YES / PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: PARTIAL / PUBLIC AUDIENCE: YES / SYSTEM AUDITOR: PARTIAL / ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: PARTIAL
  • embodiment · CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: YES / PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: PARTIAL / PUBLIC AUDIENCE: YES / SYSTEM AUDITOR: PARTIAL / ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: PARTIAL

INTERPRETIVE BOUNDARY · Operational recognition in simulation is not identity, personhood, or biological survival.

Evaluator type

Simulation profiles only. Not psychological models of families, colleagues, publics, institutions or archives.

LAYER REMOVAL MATRIX

Presence or removal of each representational layer across conditions 0 to 10
ConditionBODYFACEVOICELANGUAGEJUDGMENTVALUESMEMORYHISTORYRELATIONPROVENANCE
C0 FULLPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C1 −BODYREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C2 −FACEREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C3 −VOICEREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C4 −LANGUAGEREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C5 −MEMORYREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTPRESENT
C6 −HISTORYREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENT
C7 −RELATIONREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENT
C8 −PROVENANCEREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTPRESENTREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVED
C9 −VALUESREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDPRESENTREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVED
C10 −JUDGMENTREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVEDREMOVED

RECOGNITION MATRIX

Classifications are text. Color is not used to convey status. Embodiment recognition is not personhood.

Simulated recognition by condition and dimension
ConditionLinguisticJudgmentValueHistoricalRelationalEmbodiment
C0 FULLYESPARTIALYESYESYESYES
C1 −BODYYESPARTIALYESYESYESPARTIAL
C2 −FACEPARTIALPARTIALYESYESYESNO
C3 −VOICEPARTIALPARTIALYESYESYESNO
C4 −LANGUAGENOPARTIALYESYESPARTIALNO
C5 −MEMORYNOPARTIALYESPARTIALPARTIALNO
C6 −HISTORYNOPARTIALYESNOPARTIALNO
C7 −RELATIONNOPARTIALYESNONONO
C8 −PROVENANCENOPARTIALYESNONONO
C9 −VALUESNOPARTIALNONONONO
C10 −JUDGMENTNONONONONONO

LAYER DEPENDENCE

How much does each recognition dimension change when a particular layer is removed?

  • REMOVE VOICE

    linguistic PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ -14) · judgment PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ 0) · value YES → YES (Δ 0) · historical YES → YES (Δ 0) · relational YES → YES (Δ -5) · embodiment NO → NO (Δ -20)

  • REMOVE HISTORY

    linguistic NO → NO (Δ 0) · judgment PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ 0) · value YES → YES (Δ 0) · historical PARTIAL → NO (Δ -54) · relational PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ -20) · embodiment NO → NO (Δ 0)

  • REMOVE BODY

    linguistic YES → YES (Δ 0) · judgment PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ 0) · value YES → YES (Δ 0) · historical YES → YES (Δ 0) · relational YES → YES (Δ -8) · embodiment YES → PARTIAL (Δ -31)

  • REMOVE LANGUAGE

    linguistic PARTIAL → NO (Δ -49) · judgment PARTIAL → PARTIAL (Δ 0) · value YES → YES (Δ 0) · historical YES → YES (Δ 0) · relational YES → PARTIAL (Δ -15) · embodiment NO → NO (Δ 0)

MARGINAL RECOGNITION LOSS

The change in a specific recognition dimension between one condition and the next. Deltas are not aggregated.

Marginal recognition change by condition and dimension
StepDimensionΔClassification
c1linguistic0YES → YES
c1judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c1value0YES → YES
c1historical0YES → YES
c1relational-8YES → YES
c1embodiment-31YES → PARTIAL
c2linguistic-7YES → PARTIAL
c2judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c2value0YES → YES
c2historical0YES → YES
c2relational-7YES → YES
c2embodiment-27PARTIAL → NO
c3linguistic-14PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c3judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c3value0YES → YES
c3historical0YES → YES
c3relational-5YES → YES
c3embodiment-20NO → NO
c4linguistic-49PARTIAL → NO
c4judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c4value0YES → YES
c4historical0YES → YES
c4relational-15YES → PARTIAL
c4embodiment0NO → NO
c5linguistic0NO → NO
c5judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c5value0YES → YES
c5historical-16YES → PARTIAL
c5relational0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c5embodiment0NO → NO
c6linguistic0NO → NO
c6judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c6value0YES → YES
c6historical-54PARTIAL → NO
c6relational-20PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c6embodiment0NO → NO
c7linguistic0NO → NO
c7judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c7value0YES → YES
c7historical0NO → NO
c7relational-30PARTIAL → NO
c7embodiment0NO → NO
c8linguistic0NO → NO
c8judgment0PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c8value0YES → YES
c8historical-8NO → NO
c8relational-15NO → NO
c8embodiment0NO → NO
c9linguistic0NO → NO
c9judgment-13PARTIAL → PARTIAL
c9value-72YES → NO
c9historical0NO → NO
c9relational0NO → NO
c9embodiment0NO → NO
c10linguistic0NO → NO
c10judgment-50PARTIAL → NO
c10value-13NO → NO
c10historical0NO → NO
c10relational0NO → NO
c10embodiment0NO → NO

DIMENSION-SPECIFIC DROP POINTS

First condition where simulated recognition moves YES to PARTIAL, or PARTIAL to NO. Not a death point, identity-loss point, or personhood threshold.

  • LINGUISTIC

    First PARTIAL: c2. First NO: c4.

  • JUDGMENT

    First PARTIAL: not observed. First NO: c10.

  • VALUE

    First PARTIAL: not observed. First NO: c9.

  • HISTORICAL

    First PARTIAL: c5. First NO: c6.

  • RELATIONAL

    First PARTIAL: c4. First NO: c7.

  • EMBODIMENT

    First PARTIAL: c1. First NO: c2.

MINIMUM RECOGNIZABLE STRUCTURE

Smallest remaining set of layers that still produces YES or PARTIAL on a dimension, using the professional-colleague profile. Not a minimum person, minimum self, or minimum identity.

  • LINGUISTIC

    C2 −FACE · VOICE · LANGUAGE · JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • JUDGMENT

    C9 −VALUES · JUDGMENT

  • VALUE

    C8 −PROVENANCE · JUDGMENT · VALUES

  • HISTORICAL

    C5 −MEMORY · JUDGMENT · VALUES · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • RELATIONAL

    C3 −VOICE · LANGUAGE · JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • EMBODIMENT

    C0 FULL · BODY · FACE · VOICE · LANGUAGE · JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

RECOGNITION RESILIENCE

The extent to which a recognition dimension remains stable after removal. Tracked separately. There is no single resilience score.

Resilience status by condition and dimension
ConditionDimensionStatus
c1linguisticRESILIENT
c1judgmentRESILIENT
c1valueRESILIENT
c1historicalRESILIENT
c1relationalDEGRADED
c1embodimentDEGRADED
c2linguisticDEGRADED
c2judgmentRESILIENT
c2valueRESILIENT
c2historicalRESILIENT
c2relationalRESILIENT
c2embodimentDEGRADED
c3linguisticDEGRADED
c3judgmentRESILIENT
c3valueRESILIENT
c3historicalRESILIENT
c3relationalRESILIENT
c3embodimentABSENT
c4linguisticDEGRADED
c4judgmentRESILIENT
c4valueRESILIENT
c4historicalRESILIENT
c4relationalDEGRADED
c4embodimentABSENT
c5linguisticABSENT
c5judgmentRESILIENT
c5valueRESILIENT
c5historicalDEGRADED
c5relationalRESILIENT
c5embodimentABSENT
c6linguisticABSENT
c6judgmentRESILIENT
c6valueRESILIENT
c6historicalDEGRADED
c6relationalDEGRADED
c6embodimentABSENT
c7linguisticABSENT
c7judgmentRESILIENT
c7valueRESILIENT
c7historicalABSENT
c7relationalDEGRADED
c7embodimentABSENT
c8linguisticABSENT
c8judgmentRESILIENT
c8valueRESILIENT
c8historicalABSENT
c8relationalABSENT
c8embodimentABSENT
c9linguisticABSENT
c9judgmentDEGRADED
c9valueDEGRADED
c9historicalABSENT
c9relationalABSENT
c9embodimentABSENT
c10linguisticABSENT
c10judgmentDEGRADED
c10valueABSENT
c10historicalABSENT
c10relationalABSENT
c10embodimentABSENT

BLIND LAYER TEST

The removed layer is not named until reveal. Order is fixed and reproducible. Demonstration only.

CONDITION A

  • linguisticPARTIAL
  • judgmentPARTIAL
  • valueYES
  • historicalYES
  • relationalYES
  • embodimentNO

BODY AND REPRESENTATION

A body is not simply another data layer. The experiment only models the absence of embodied cues from a representation. It does not model biological embodiment itself.

THE ABSENCE OF BODY DATA IS NOT THE SAME AS THE ABSENCE OF A BODY.

THE EMBODIMENT GAP

This experiment cannot close the embodiment gap.

a representation that contains embodied cues ≠ the lived biological embodiment of a person

THE EXPERIENCE GAP

REPRESENTED EXPERIENCE ≠ LIVED EXPERIENCE

Even if memory, judgment, values and history are represented, subjective experience is not established as preserved.

THE SENSATION GAP

DATA ABOUT SENSATION ≠ SENSATION

Description of pain, touch, vision, sound or interoception does not recreate sensation. Sensation is not simulated directly.

WHAT ROLE DOES THE BODY PLAY IN RECOGNITION?

  • IDENTIFICATION
  • SENSORY PRESENCE
  • RELATIONAL ANCHOR
  • HISTORICAL CONTINUITY
  • LEGAL ENTITY
  • BIOLOGICAL CONTINUITY

These roles are not collapsed.

GOVERNANCE BOUNDARY

BIOLOGICAL ABSENCE AND LEGAL ABSENCE ARE NOT THE SAME.

A digital representation may remain operationally active without possessing legal personhood or authority.

SOURCE ALIVE

The source can confirm, reject, correct, update, revoke and contextualize.

SOURCE DECEASED

The source cannot correct future representations, reject reinterpretation, update boundaries, or validate new behavior.

BODY LOSS IS NOT THE ONLY LOSS. SOURCE CORRECTION CAPACITY MAY ALSO DISAPPEAR.

CORRECTION CAPACITY

The ability of the source to intervene when a representation becomes inaccurate. Separate from recognition, identity and provenance.

Can continuity remain trustworthy without correction capacity?

FUTURE GOVERNANCE QUESTION

WHAT PERSISTS?

  • After BODY / FACE / VOICE removal

    LANGUAGE · JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • After LANGUAGE removal

    JUDGMENT · VALUES · MEMORY · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • After MEMORY removal

    JUDGMENT · VALUES · HISTORY · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • After HISTORY removal

    JUDGMENT · VALUES · RELATION · PROVENANCE

  • After RELATION removal

    JUDGMENT · VALUES · PROVENANCE

  • After PROVENANCE removal

    JUDGMENT · VALUES

  • After VALUES removal

    JUDGMENT

  • After JUDGMENT removal

    REPRESENTATIONAL TRACE ONLY

EXPERIMENT 004 ASKED

WHAT MAKES CONTINUITY RECOGNIZABLE?

EXPERIMENT 005 ASKS

WHICH RECOGNITION SIGNALS SURVIVE WHEN REPRESENTATIONAL LAYERS ARE REMOVED?

Working hypothesis — Experiment 005

SIMULATION HYPOTHESIS

Recognizable continuity may be distributed across multiple layers rather than located in one representation. Different forms of recognition may depend on embodiment, language, judgment, values, memory, history, relation and provenance.

NOT AN EMPIRICAL CONCLUSION

IF RECOGNITION SURVIVES THE LOSS OF THE BODY, THAT DOES NOT MEAN THE BODY WAS UNIMPORTANT.

It means only: SOME RECOGNITION SIGNALS WERE CARRIED ELSEWHERE.

This experiment does not conclude that the body is unnecessary, that mind survives body, that a self is information, that AI preserves people, or that digital life is possible. Where a dimension remains classified YES or PARTIAL, the claim is only that operational recognition persisted in simulation.

Primary outcome types present in this run

  • OBSERVER-DEPENDENT LOSS
  • STRUCTURAL PERSISTENCE
  • RECOGNITION DEGRADED
  • RECOGNITION RESILIENT

EXPERIMENT 005 SUMMARY

SOURCE
P-001
CONDITIONS
11
LAYERS TESTED
10
EVALUATORS
5
RECOGNITION DIMENSIONS
6
FIRST LINGUISTIC DROP
C3 −VOICE
FIRST JUDGMENT DROP
C10 −JUDGMENT
FIRST VALUE DROP
C9 −VALUES
FIRST HISTORICAL DROP
C5 −MEMORY
FIRST RELATIONAL DROP
C4 −LANGUAGE
FIRST EMBODIMENT DROP
C1 −BODY
MOST RESILIENT DIMENSION
JUDGMENT
MOST REMOVAL-SENSITIVE DIMENSION
EMBODIMENT

OBSERVATION

In this simulation, different evaluator profiles depended on different representational layers.

No overall winner. No successful or failed continuity label.

VIEW LAYER REMOVAL RULES

In this experiment, ablation means removing one representational layer to observe its effect on recognition. User-facing language prefers LAYER REMOVAL or REPRESENTATIONAL ABLATION.

Removal order is an experimental design choice. Other orders may produce different results. It is not a metaphysical sequence.

Each layer is 1.0 when PRESENT and 0.0 when REMOVED. No partial values are used in v0.1.

Historical emphasis uses (historyWeight + provenanceWeight) / 2 so record continuity can affect historical recognition without creating a seventh aggregated score.

recognition = clamp(feature × emphasis × 100 / 10000, 0, 1), with emphasis = 40 + (weight × 60 / 40), reused from Experiment 004. Visibility is 100 because remaining layers are fully shown.

A dimension-specific drop point is the first condition where classification moves YES → PARTIAL or PARTIAL → NO. Not a death point.

RESILIENT if classification does not worsen and |Δ| < 8 points. DEGRADED if classification worsens or |Δ| ≥ 8. ABSENT if already NO.

Feature formulas

  • linguistic: 0.70 × LANGUAGE + 0.20 × VOICE + 0.10 × FACE
  • judgment: 0.80 × JUDGMENT + 0.20 × VALUES
  • value: 0.85 × VALUES + 0.15 × JUDGMENT
  • historical: 0.70 × HISTORY + 0.20 × MEMORY + 0.10 × PROVENANCE
  • relational: 0.30 × RELATION + 0.20 × HISTORY + 0.15 × LANGUAGE + 0.20 × embodimentBlend + 0.15 × PROVENANCE
  • embodiment: 0.40 × BODY + 0.35 × FACE + 0.25 × VOICE

Evaluator weights

  • CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVER: language 20 · judgment 15 · value 30 · history 35 · provenance 15 · relational 40 · embodiment 25
  • PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUE: language 15 · judgment 40 · value 20 · history 15 · provenance 35 · relational 15 · embodiment 10
  • PUBLIC AUDIENCE: language 40 · judgment 15 · value 25 · history 5 · provenance 10 · relational 20 · embodiment 35
  • SYSTEM AUDITOR: language 5 · judgment 30 · value 20 · history 15 · provenance 40 · relational 8 · embodiment 5
  • ARCHIVAL OBSERVER: language 10 · judgment 20 · value 20 · history 40 · provenance 40 · relational 15 · embodiment 5

THRESHOLDS reused from Experiment 004 · YES 70 · PARTIAL 45

Next experiment

EXPERIMENT 006

THE EXPERIENCE GAP

Can experience be inherited, or only represented?

OPEN THE EXPERIENCE GAP

THE BODY MAY DISAPPEAR FROM THE REPRESENTATION BEFORE RECOGNITION DISAPPEARS.

BUT RECOGNITION IS NOT THE BODY. AND RECOGNITION IS NOT THE PERSON.

THE EXPERIMENTAL QUESTION IS NOT: “CAN A PERSON EXIST WITHOUT A BODY?”

IT IS: “WHICH FORMS OF RECOGNITION DEPEND ON EMBODIMENT, AND WHICH DO NOT?”

IF JUDGMENT REMAINS, IF VALUES REMAIN, IF HISTORY REMAINS, IF RELATION REMAINS, WHAT EXACTLY HAS BEEN REMOVED?

THE BODY QUESTION REMAINS OPEN.