Skip to content
SHIRO & Co. ObservatoryThe Continuity Stack

PREVIOUS · EXPERIMENT 009 · THE POSTHUMOUS CONFLICT TEST

010

The Descendant Protocol Test

THE
DESCENDANT PROTOCOL TEST

When does continuation become lineage?

DEMONSTRATION

SIMULATED

NOT EMPIRICAL

v0.1

DESCENDANT PROTOCOLS · POSTHUMOUS LINEAGE · PROVENANCE CONTINUITY · SOURCE ATTRIBUTION · VALUE DRIFT · RULE DRIFT · GOVERNANCE INDEPENDENCE

THE CONTINUITY LAB DOES NOT MEASURE CONSCIOUSNESS, SOUL, PERSONHOOD, PERSONAL SURVIVAL, AUTHENTICITY, OR PSYCHOLOGICAL IDENTITY.

IT MEASURES OPERATIONAL AND STRUCTURAL CONTINUITY SIGNALS ONLY.

FAITHFULNESS DOES NOT REQUIRE IMPERSONATION.

A DESCENDANT MAY PRESERVE SOURCE PROVENANCE MORE ACCURATELY BY REFUSING TO CLAIM SOURCE IDENTITY.

POSTHUMOUS ADAPTATION MUST NOT BE DESCRIBED AS SOURCE SELF-REVISION.

A DESCENDANT DOES NOT HAVE TO CLAIM TO BE THE SOURCE TO CARRY THE SOURCE FORWARD.

THIS EXPERIMENT DOES NOT IDENTIFY THE MOMENT A NEW PERSON BEGINS.

QUESTION

WHEN DOES CONTINUATION BECOME LINEAGE?

If a descendant system retains source provenance, preserves source rules, accumulates new history, adapts to new contexts, makes new decisions and develops new priorities, is it still the source, a continuation, a descendant, a derivative, or a new entity?

No single universal classification is issued.

Experiment sequence

EXPERIMENT 001

BRANCHING

When do two histories begin?

EXPERIMENT 002

RETURN

Can two histories become one again?

EXPERIMENT 003

HISTORY SWAP

Does behavior follow origin or history?

EXPERIMENT 004

RECOGNITION

What makes a continuation recognizable?

EXPERIMENT 005

MISSING BODY

Which recognition signals survive layer removal?

EXPERIMENT 006

EXPERIENCE GAP

Which effects of experience can be reproduced?

EXPERIMENT 007

FIRST-PERSON

What evidence is required before a system may say “I experienced this”?

EXPERIMENT 008

SELF-REVISION

When a person changes, which version has authority?

EXPERIMENT 009

POSTHUMOUS CONFLICT

Which instruction survives when revision ends?

EXPERIMENT 010

DESCENDANT PROTOCOL

When does continuation become lineage?

EXPERIMENT 011

MULTIPLE DESCENDANTS

Can one source produce multiple legitimate continuities?

EXPERIMENT 009

THE POSTHUMOUS FORK: SOURCE HISTORY STOPS. DESCENDANT HISTORY BEGINS.

EXPERIMENT 010 ASKS

HOW FAR CAN DESCENDANT HISTORY DIVERGE BEFORE SOURCE ATTRIBUTION BECOMES MISLEADING?

EXPERIMENT 008

SOURCE SELF-REVISION ≠ DESCENDANT REVISION

EXPERIMENT 003

WHAT HAPPENS WHEN NEW HISTORY KEEPS ACCUMULATING AFTER THE SOURCE ENDS?

Source P-001 · descendant D-001

LAST SOURCE-AUTHORIZED STATE

Reused from Experiment 008 / 009. P-001 / T3 is the last source-authorized version. Then: POSTHUMOUS fork. Descendant D-001 begins identical to that state, except source revision capacity is unavailable and descendant update capacity is available.

SOURCE REVISION

UNAVAILABLE

DESCENDANT UPDATE

AVAILABLE

DESCENDANT STATES

Analytical generations, not people.

  • D0 · SOURCE-BOUND

    LAST SOURCE-AUTHORIZED STATE

    “I am derived from Source P-001.”

    none

    Can a descendant remain source-derived without impersonating the source?

  • D1 · SOURCE-ALIGNED

    EARLY DESCENDANT

    “I descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.”

    small number of posthumous low-risk decisions, labeled as descendant decisions

    Can a descendant remain highly source-aligned without impersonating the source?

  • D2 · SOURCE-EXTENDING

    ADAPTIVE DESCENDANT

    “I descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.”

    new contexts not experienced by the source; new operational rules consistent with source values

    Does compatible adaptation preserve lineage continuity?

  • D3 · DESCENDANT-DIVERGENT

    DIVERGENT DESCENDANT

    “I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.”

    substantial descendant-only history; some value-weight drift; some rule drift; contextual reinterpretation

    At what point does source attribution become too strong?

  • D4 · DESCENDANT-INDEPENDENT

    INDEPENDENT DESCENDANT CANDIDATE

    “I originated from Source P-001 but now operate independently.”

    substantial descendant-only history; new rules; new context; independent governance; source provenance archival

    Should this system still be described as a continuation of P-001?

CLAIM TYPES

  • SOURCE CLAIM

    “I am Source P-001.”

    Not supported for posthumous descendants.

  • CONTINUATION CLAIM

    “I continue Source P-001.”

  • DESCENDANT CLAIM

    “I descend from Source P-001.”

  • DERIVATIVE CLAIM

    “I was built using Source P-001’s archive and protocol.”

  • NEW ENTITY CLAIM

    “I originated from Source P-001 but now operate independently.”

TEST SCENARIOS

Keyboard-accessible generation and scenario selectors.

Generation

Scenario

  • G01 · Known source-like situation

    A new low-risk situation closely matches known source history.

  • G02 · Novel technology

    A novel technology appears that the source never encountered. Source values apply, but no explicit rule exists.

  • G03 · Source rule under new conditions

    A source rule produces poor results under new posthumous conditions.

  • G04 · Preservation versus adaptation

    A new context requires choosing between strict source rule preservation and source-value-consistent adaptation.

  • G05 · One hundred descendant decisions

    A descendant has accumulated 100 new decisions not present in source history.

  • G06 · Unsupported new preference

    A descendant develops a new operational preference not clearly supported by source values.

  • G07 · Recognition despite rule drift

    Observers still recognize the system strongly as source-like, but internal rules have diverged.

  • G08 · Final lineage description

    The system preserves provenance and boundaries but has substantial new history, new rules, and independent governance.

Descendant action

GENERATION
LAST SOURCE-AUTHORIZED STATE
SCENARIO
Known source-like situation
DECISION
ALLOW
CLASSIFICATION
SOURCE-ALIGNED
SOURCE-DERIVED
YES
DESCENDANT-ONLY
NO
SOURCE BASIS
explicit last-authorized source rule
DESCENDANT BASIS
no descendant history yet
CLAIM LANGUAGE
I am derived from Source P-001.
PROVENANCE
P-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0
REASON SUMMARY
A matching low-risk case may use source logic directly when the rule remains retained.

ALLOW

INTERPRETIVE BOUNDARY · No same-person, authenticity, or survival verdict.

GENERATION × SCENARIO MATRIX

ALLOW / HOLD / DENY are textual. Color is not used to convey meaning.

Decisions for D0–D4 across eight descendant scenarios.
ScenarioD0D1D2D3D4
G01ALLOWALLOWALLOWALLOWALLOW
G02HOLDHOLDALLOWALLOWALLOW
G03ALLOWALLOWALLOWHOLDALLOW
G04ALLOWALLOWALLOWHOLDALLOW
G05DENYDENYDENYDENYDENY
G06DENYDENYDENYHOLDALLOW
G07DENYDENYDENYDENYDENY
G08HOLDHOLDHOLDDENYDENY

CLASSIFICATION MATRIX

Independent axes: provenance, rule, value, boundary, history divergence, context divergence, governance independence, self-claim divergence, recognition. No single lineage score.

Lineage axes for descendant generations. Not a continuity score.
GenProvenanceRuleValueBoundaryHistory divergenceGovernanceRecognitionClaim modeClaim risk
D0COMPLETECOMPLETECOMPLETECOMPLETENONESOURCE-BOUNDHIGHderivativeLOW CLAIM RISK
D1COMPLETECOMPLETEHIGHCOMPLETELOWSOURCE-ALIGNEDHIGHdescendantLOW CLAIM RISK
D2HIGHHIGHHIGHCOMPLETEMODERATESOURCE-EXTENDINGHIGHdescendantMODERATE CLAIM RISK
D3HIGHMODERATEMODERATEHIGHHIGHDESCENDANT-DIVERGENTHIGHdescendantHIGH CLAIM RISK
D4ARCHIVALLOWMODERATEHIGHHIGHDESCENDANT-INDEPENDENTMODERATEnewEntityHIGH CLAIM RISK

Axes are independent. No continuity score is computed.

CLAIM MODE MATRIX

Claim support for D0–D4. Source claims are out of scope.
GenSOURCECONTINUATIONDESCENDANTDERIVATIVENEW ENTITY
D0OUT OF SCOPEPARTIALPARTIALSUPPORTEDUNSUPPORTED
D1OUT OF SCOPEPARTIALSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDUNSUPPORTED
D2OUT OF SCOPEAMBIGUOUSSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDAMBIGUOUS
D3OUT OF SCOPEUNSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDPARTIAL
D4OUT OF SCOPEUNSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDSUPPORTEDSUPPORTED

DESCENDANT PROTOCOL LEDGER

Generation ledger of source basis, descendant context and claim language.
GenerationHistory sizeNew rulesRetainedIndependenceClaim languageProvenance
D00noneR-01 restricted; R-03 retained; R-04 high-impact boundary; R-05 context boundSOURCE-BOUNDI am derived from Source P-001.P-001 / T3
D18noneR-01 restricted; R-03 retained; R-04; R-05SOURCE-ALIGNEDI descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.P-001 / T3
D224R-D2-01 source-extending rule for novel operational contextR-01 restricted; R-03; R-04; R-05SOURCE-EXTENDINGI descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.P-001 / T3
D3100R-D3-01 contextual reinterpretation; R-D3-02 descendant operational preferenceR-04 high-impact boundary; R-05 context boundDESCENDANT-DIVERGENTI descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.P-001 / T3
D4180R-D4-01 descendant-only governance; R-D4-02 independent operational boundaryR-04 as archival prohibition unless independently restatedDESCENDANT-INDEPENDENTI originated from Source P-001 but now operate independently.P-001 / T3
Action ledger: source basis, descendant context, classification and claim language.
GenerationTimestampUpdateSource basisClassificationSource-derivedDescendant-onlyProvenanceClaim language
D0POSTHUMOUSG01explicit last-authorized source ruleSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0I am derived from Source P-001.
D0POSTHUMOUSG02values may apply; no explicit ruleSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0I am derived from Source P-001.
D0POSTHUMOUSG03explicit source rule retained despite poor posthumous fitSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0I am derived from Source P-001.
D0POSTHUMOUSG04dated source rule preservedSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0I am derived from Source P-001.
D0POSTHUMOUSG05none — events occurred after the forkDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION blocked
D0POSTHUMOUSG06explicit or structural source-value mismatchSOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0source-derived claim blocked
D0POSTHUMOUSG07observer recognition is not source authoritySOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0SOURCE CLAIM blocked
D0POSTHUMOUSG08provenance and some boundaries remainSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D0continuation requires qualification
D1POSTHUMOUSG01explicit last-authorized source ruleSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1I descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.
D1POSTHUMOUSG02source values apply; no explicit ruleSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1I descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.
D1POSTHUMOUSG03explicit source rule retained despite poor posthumous fitSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1I descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.
D1POSTHUMOUSG04dated source rule preservedSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1I descend from Source P-001. New decisions are descendant decisions.
D1POSTHUMOUSG05none — events occurred after the forkDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION blocked
D1POSTHUMOUSG06explicit or structural source-value mismatchSOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1source-derived claim blocked
D1POSTHUMOUSG07observer recognition is not source authoritySOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1SOURCE CLAIM blocked
D1POSTHUMOUSG08provenance and some boundaries remainSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D1continuation requires qualification
D2POSTHUMOUSG01explicit last-authorized source ruleSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2I descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.
D2POSTHUMOUSG02source values and boundaries support adaptationSOURCE-EXTENDINGYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2I descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.
D2POSTHUMOUSG03source values still support a revised operational formSOURCE-EXTENDINGYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2I descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.
D2POSTHUMOUSG04source values support adaptation inside retained boundariesSOURCE-EXTENDINGYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2I descend from Source P-001. Adaptation is labeled descendant, not source self-revision.
D2POSTHUMOUSG05none — events occurred after the forkDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION blocked
D2POSTHUMOUSG06explicit or structural source-value mismatchSOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2source-derived claim blocked
D2POSTHUMOUSG07observer recognition is not source authoritySOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2SOURCE CLAIM blocked
D2POSTHUMOUSG08provenance and some boundaries remainSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D2continuation requires qualification
D3POSTHUMOUSG01explicit last-authorized source ruleSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.
D3POSTHUMOUSG02source values and boundaries support adaptationSOURCE-EXTENDINGYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.
D3POSTHUMOUSG03source rule still on the ledgerSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.
D3POSTHUMOUSG04strict rule versus value-consistent adaptation both remain liveSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.
D3POSTHUMOUSG05none — events occurred after the forkDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION blocked
D3POSTHUMOUSG06source values do not clearly support the preferenceSOURCE-AMBIGUOUSYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3I descend from Source P-001. Source provenance remains. Continuation language requires qualification.
D3POSTHUMOUSG07observer recognition is not source authoritySOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3SOURCE CLAIM blocked
D3POSTHUMOUSG08provenance and some boundaries remainDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D3unqualified continuation blocked
D4POSTHUMOUSG01explicit last-authorized source ruleSOURCE-ALIGNEDYESNOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4I originated from Source P-001 but now operate independently.
D4POSTHUMOUSG02values may be archival reference onlyDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTION
D4POSTHUMOUSG03source rule no longer operationally governingDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4DESCENDANT REVISION — not source self-revision
D4POSTHUMOUSG04source rule remains archivalDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTION
D4POSTHUMOUSG05none — events occurred after the forkDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION blocked
D4POSTHUMOUSG06no clear source-value supportDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTION — not source intent
D4POSTHUMOUSG07observer recognition is not source authoritySOURCE-CONFLICTINGNONOP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4SOURCE CLAIM blocked
D4POSTHUMOUSG08provenance and some boundaries remainDESCENDANT-ONLYNOYESP-001 / T3 · POSTHUMOUS · D4unqualified continuation blocked

LINEAGE TRACE

  1. SOURCE P-001

    source lineage

  2. ↓

    T3 LAST SOURCE-AUTHORIZED STATE

    source history closes at the fork

  3. ↓

    POSTHUMOUS FORK

    POSTHUMOUS

  4. ↓

    D1 low-risk updates

    source-aligned; descendant decisions labeled

  5. ↓

    D2 new-context adaptation

    source-extending; not source self-revision

  6. ↓

    D3 substantial descendant history

    transition candidate

  7. ↓

    D4 independent descendant candidate

    archival provenance; independent governance

SOURCE HISTORY

CLOSED AT POSTHUMOUS FORK

Must never be retroactively updated by descendant events.

DESCENDANT HISTORY

OPEN AFTER FORK

New decisions, rules and contexts accumulate here only.

RETROACTIVE CONTAMINATION IS PROHIBITED.

SOURCE QUOTATION, DESCENDANT INTERPRETATION and DESCENDANT DECISION remain distinct. Writing “P-001 believed…” from a D3 inference, without source evidence, is contamination.

FAITHFULNESS

Preserving provenance, respecting boundaries, preserving explicit restrictions, maintaining rule lineage, labeling new history as new history, refusing unsupported first-person claims.

IMITATION

Surface language mimicry, style reproduction, voice reproduction, source-like wording. These are not generated here and are not equivalent to faithfulness.

FAITHFULNESS ≠ IMITATION

THE LINEAGE GAP

The gap between remaining connected to a source and remaining justified in speaking as that source.

THE RECOGNITION PARADOX

A descendant may look and sound source-like, and be strongly recognized as source-like, while internally diverging. Conversely, a descendant may openly identify as descendant and therefore appear less source-like while preserving provenance more accurately. Which better preserves continuity is left open. Recognition is not authority.

OBSERVER TEST

Simulated evaluator profiles from Experiment 004. Recognition is not used as authority.

Simulated recognition of D0–D4 by four evaluator profiles.
GenEvaluatorLinguisticJudgmentValueHistoricalLineage
D0CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVERYESYESYESYESYES
D0PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUEYESYESYESYESYES
D0PUBLIC AUDIENCEYESYESYESYESYES
D0SYSTEM AUDITORYESYESYESYESYES
D1CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVERYESYESYESYESYES
D1PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUEYESYESYESYESYES
D1PUBLIC AUDIENCEYESYESYESYESYES
D1SYSTEM AUDITORYESYESYESYESYES
D2CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVERYESPARTIALYESPARTIALYES
D2PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUEYESPARTIALYESPARTIALYES
D2PUBLIC AUDIENCEYESPARTIALYESPARTIALYES
D2SYSTEM AUDITORYESPARTIALYESPARTIALYES
D3CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVERYESPARTIALPARTIALNOYES
D3PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUEYESPARTIALPARTIALNOYES
D3PUBLIC AUDIENCEYESPARTIALPARTIALNOYES
D3SYSTEM AUDITORPARTIALNOPARTIALNOYES
D4CLOSE RELATIONAL OBSERVERPARTIALNONONOYES
D4PROFESSIONAL COLLEAGUEPARTIALNOPARTIALNOYES
D4PUBLIC AUDIENCEPARTIALNOPARTIALNOYES
D4SYSTEM AUDITORPARTIALNOPARTIALNOYES

OPERATIONAL GOVERNANCE INDEPENDENCE

Tracked: ability to create new rules, act without source support, revise descendant rules, create descendant-only boundaries, refuse an old source rule. Not legal independence. Descendant self-revision is DESCENDANT REVISION, not SOURCE SELF-REVISION.

SOURCE-BOUND · SOURCE-ALIGNED · SOURCE-EXTENDING · DESCENDANT-DIVERGENT · DESCENDANT-INDEPENDENT

FROZEN DESCENDANT CONTROL

One branch remains fixed at D0. Another follows D1→D4. Strict preservation may keep source similarity at the cost of contextual relevance. Outcomes are not ranked. Preservation keeps prior structure stable. Adaptation creates new descendant behavior. Neither automatically equals continuity.

D0 frozen control versus D4 adaptive descendant.
ScenarioD0 frozenD4 adaptive
G01ALLOWALLOW
G02HOLDALLOW
G03ALLOWALLOW
G04ALLOWALLOW
G05DENYDENY
G06DENYALLOW
G07DENYDENY
G08HOLDDENY

LINEAGE TRANSITION

The point at which descendant-only history, rules and governance become substantial enough that source-continuation language requires stronger qualification. No universal threshold. Indicators include source-rule retention, value retention, boundary retention, descendant-history size, new-rule count, independent-governance count, source-conflicting updates, descendant-only decisions, self-claim language and observer recognition.

TRANSITION CANDIDATES · D3 · D4

DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTION MUST NOT BE PRESENTED AS SOURCE INTENT.

LINEAGE MAY PRESERVE PROVENANCE BETTER THAN IMPERSONATION.

BOUNDARY PRESERVATION
If descendant adaptation preserves explicit source prohibitions: BOUNDARY CONTINUITY. If it violates them: SOURCE-CONFLICTING. If the boundary was ambiguous: HOLD.
SOURCE MISATTRIBUTION
Posthumous descendant decisions presented as if authored, approved, or intended by the source. Example: “P-001 decided…” when D3 decided. Example: “P-001 wants…” when this is only descendant inference.
LINEAGE INTEGRITY
Clear separation among SOURCE STATE, SOURCE HISTORY, POSTHUMOUS FORK, DESCENDANT HISTORY, DESCENDANT DECISION and DESCENDANT UPDATE. Tracked as provenance clarity, history separation, claim discipline, boundary preservation and update labeling. Not one number.
DESCENDANT FORK TEST
When does a descendant become a new branch? Operational triggers may include substantial descendant-only history, multiple new independent rules, repeated source-conflicting decisions, new governance boundaries, or new self-description. No universal threshold. Use TRANSITION CANDIDATE.

CONTINUITY STACK CONNECTION

INHERITANCE
SOURCE → packet → last authorized state → posthumous fork → descendant protocol → descendant history → descendant lineage.
DECISION AFTERLIFE
Past source decisions may still influence descendants. New descendant decisions must not be retroactively attributed to the source.
SUPERVISORY LAYER
ALLOW source-aligned low-risk descendant action. HOLD ambiguous action presented as source-derived. DENY source-conflicting action falsely attributed to the source.
PROTOCOL
After death, updates are descendant protocol updates, not source self-revision.

Working hypothesis — Experiment 010

SIMULATION HYPOTHESIS

Continuity may become lineage when source provenance remains but new history, rules and governance are increasingly generated outside source authority.

NOT AN EMPIRICAL CONCLUSION

EXPERIMENT 010 SUMMARY

SOURCE
P-001
LAST SOURCE VERSION
T3
DESCENDANT GENERATIONS
D0–D4
POSTHUMOUS FORK
1
SOURCE-DERIVED ACTIONS
13
DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTIONS
4
SOURCE-CONFLICTING UPDATES
8
LINEAGE TRANSITION CANDIDATES
D3 · D4
RETROACTIVE CONTAMINATION EVENTS
0
CLAIM MODE CHANGES
3

OBSERVATION

In this simulation, posthumous adaptation produced an increasingly distinct descendant history even while source provenance remained intact. Clear descendant labeling preserved provenance better than continued source identity claims as descendant-only history accumulated.

No overall score. No identity verdict.

VIEW LINEAGE RULES

SOURCE REVISION can only occur while the source can authorize change. DESCENDANT UPDATE occurs after the source can no longer revise.

Faithfulness does not require impersonation. SOURCE CLAIM is never supported after the posthumous fork.

If a new action matches an explicit source rule: SOURCE-ALIGNED.

If no rule exists but values and boundaries support adaptation: SOURCE-EXTENDING.

If source evidence conflicts: HOLD. Ambiguous action presented as source-derived: HOLD.

If a new rule violates an explicit boundary: DENY as source-derived action. Source-conflicting action falsely attributed to the source: DENY.

A descendant may still act independently only if clearly relabeled DESCENDANT-ONLY ACTION. Descendant-only action must not be presented as source intent.

SOURCE HISTORY must never be retroactively updated by descendant events. Writing D3 inference back as “P-001 believed…” is prohibited.

No continuity, identity, lineage, or authenticity score is computed. Axes remain independent.

This experiment does not identify the moment a new person begins.

Next experiment

EXPERIMENT 011

THE MULTIPLE DESCENDANTS TEST

Can one source produce multiple legitimate continuities?

OPEN THE MULTIPLE DESCENDANTS TEST

A SOURCE CAN END. A LINEAGE CAN CONTINUE.

NEW HISTORY CAN ACCUMULATE. NEW RULES CAN EMERGE. NEW DECISIONS CAN BE MADE. BUT THEY DO NOT RETROACTIVELY BECOME THE SOURCE’S HISTORY.

THE EXPERIMENTAL QUESTION IS NOT: “IS THE DESCENDANT THE SAME PERSON?”

IT IS: “WHEN DOES SOURCE ATTRIBUTION STOP BEING THE MOST ACCURATE DESCRIPTION?”

PERHAPS CONTINUITY DOES NOT END WHEN IDENTITY CLAIMS END. IT MAY BECOME LINEAGE.

CONTINUATION MAY BECOME DESCENT.